Journal

Tri Tip for Thanksgiving In place of the turkey, or next to it

Turkey Day is coming up, but it doesn’t have to be turkey. Not every family loves the bird, and some put out a ham instead. Not every Thanksgiving is a big crowd, either. A smaller get-together doesn’t call for a huge turkey and a day spent watching the oven.

Published:

Two seasoned tri tips side by side on a Weber kettle grill, with the coals banked to one side.

Tri tip is a great main for both. It’s less trouble than a turkey, it cooks in about an hour, you slice it right at the table, and it looks like a holiday sitting on a board. The mashed potatoes still go with it, and so do most of the sides you already make. And if your crew wants to keep the turkey, tri tip still earns a spot next to it. Here’s how to do it either way.

Why Tri Tip Instead of Turkey

Turkey is a lot of trouble. It takes days to thaw, a lot of people brine it, and then it takes over the oven for most of the day. That’s a big job for any table, and a lot of bird for a small one.

Not every family loves turkey, either. Plenty of tables put out a ham instead. And plenty of Thanksgivings are small: a couple, a few friends, a family of four. A whole turkey is a lot to take on for that.

Tri tip fits all of it. One roast feeds a small table, a few more feed a crowd, and it’s on and off the grill in about an hour. Thanksgiving is about the people at the table and a big meal you share. Nothing says the meat in the middle has to be a turkey.

Tri Tip as the Main

If the weather lets you and you have the time and the gear, cook it outside. That’s always our call. Santa Maria Style Tri Tip is the one to make: salt, pepper and garlic over a hot fire. It’s the classic, and it lets the sides do their thing. For the most even pink at a sit-down dinner, use the reverse sear: low heat until the center reads 115 to 120°F, then a hard sear.

Rain, wind or no grill? The oven works. With no turkey in there, it’s all yours, and Oven-Roasted Tri Tip gets you there indoors.

Having more people over? Grab a few more tri tips. Two or three roasts cook side by side in the same time as one. For a smaller table, one roast may be all you need. Run your head count through the serving calculator. With tri tip as the only meat, go with the full amount, not the low end.

Slice It at the Table

This is where tri tip has the turkey beat. There’s no carving job back in the kitchen while the food gets cold. Bring the whole roast out on a big cutting board and slice it right there. It looks great on the table, everybody gets to watch, and the first slices go onto plates hot.

Make Board Sauce right on the board before you start: butter, garlic and herbs, and the juices mix in as you cut.

Tri tip has two grains that meet in the middle. Cut the roast in half where they meet, then slice each half against its own grain. How to cut tri tip shows where.

The Thanksgiving Sides Still Work

Changing the main doesn’t mean giving up the spread. Mashed potatoes go with tri tip as well as they go with turkey, maybe better. Most of the classics carry over: stuffing, green beans, rolls.

The one thing to leave behind is the turkey gravy. Tri tip has its own sauces: Horseradish Cream, Chimichurri, or the Board Sauce you made while slicing.

Want a few sides from the tri tip side of the table? Pinquito Beans, Santa Maria Green Salad, Grilled Garlic Bread, Grilled Broccolini and Smoked Mac and Cheese all fit a holiday table. Pouring wine? Central Coast wine and beer for tri tip.

Next to the Turkey

If the turkey stays, its rest is your window. Light the grill about an hour before the turkey is due out. The tri tip comes off the fire as the turkey comes out of the oven, both rest, and both get carved and reach the table hot.

Want the bird outside too? Over at BBQ Junkie, Smoked BBQ Turkey on a Weber Kettle Grill does a whole turkey on a kettle in about three hours, and it frees up the oven for the pies and the sides. A turkey fills the kettle, so give the tri tip its own grill.

With turkey on the table too, you need less tri tip than you would for a tri tip dinner. Use the serving calculator and buy toward the low end.

If the Santa Anas are blowing on Thanksgiving, the grill is out and the oven is taken. Use the counter instead: Slow Cooker Tri Tip runs all day without the oven.

Timing the Day

  • The day before: Mix the Santa Maria Seasoning. Make the Pinquito Beans and the Central Coast Sangria.
  • The morning of: Stir together the Horseradish Cream Sauce and chill it.
  • An hour before dinner: Season the tri tip and let it sit out 30 minutes. Light the fire. If there’s a turkey too, time it so the tri tip comes off as the turkey comes out.
  • The last stretch: Sear, finish on the cool side, rest 10 to 15 minutes. Grilled Garlic Bread goes on the fire while the meat rests.
  • At the table: Make the Board Sauce, slice against the grain and pass the sauces.

Leftovers

Leftover tri tip makes Friday easy. Slice it cold and thin for a Tri Tip Sandwich or a Tri Tip Salad, or warm it up for Tri Tip Tacos. How to reheat tri tip keeps it from drying out.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can tri tip be the main for Thanksgiving?

Yes. It cooks in about an hour, slices at the table, and goes with mashed potatoes and most traditional sides. For a big table, cook two or three roasts side by side. Santa Maria Style Tri Tip is the one to start with.

Is tri tip good for a small Thanksgiving?

Yes. One roast can feed a small table, and it’s far less trouble than a whole turkey. The serving calculator tells you how much to buy.

Can I cook tri tip in the oven for Thanksgiving?

Yes. With no turkey in it, the oven is free, and Oven-Roasted Tri Tip covers it. If the weather lets you and you have the gear, the grill is still the way to go.

How much tri tip do I need for Thanksgiving?

It depends on whether there’s a turkey. As the only meat, use the full amount from the serving calculator. Next to a turkey, buy toward the low end.

What sides go with tri tip at Thanksgiving?

Mashed potatoes and most of the classic Thanksgiving sides. Skip the turkey gravy and pass a tri tip sauce like Horseradish Cream or Chimichurri.

Can I cook tri tip in the oven with the turkey?

Not at the same time. Tri tip roasts at 425°F, hotter than the turkey wants, and opening the oven to sear and check a second roast costs the turkey heat. Use the grill, or the slow cooker on the counter.

Can I cook the tri tip the day before?

Yes. Cook it to medium-rare, chill it whole, then warm it gently before you slice it. How to reheat tri tip covers how to keep it from drying out.