Best Wood for Tri Tip
Tri tip is lean, with a clean, beefy flavor, so heavy smoke buries it fast. Pick a wood that seasons the beef without covering it. The wood also changes how your rub reads on the crust. The chart runs from best to last for Santa Maria style tri tip.
| Wood | Flavor | Strength | For tri tip |
|---|---|---|---|
| Red Oak | Clean, slightly sweet, earthy | Medium | The Santa Maria standard. Best all-around. |
| Post Oak, White Oak | Clean, mild | Medium | The closest match to red oak outside California. |
| Cherry | Mild, sweet, fruity | Mild | Mahogany color. Alone or 70/30 with oak. |
| Almond | Sweet, lightly nutty | Mild | A California orchard wood. Hard to overdo. |
| Pecan | Sweet, nutty | Mild to medium | Forgiving. Blends well with cherry. |
| Apple, Peach | Light, sweet | Mild | Too soft alone. Blend 50/50 with oak. |
| Hickory | Bold, bacony, sharp | Strong | One chunk in an oak fire at most. |
| Mesquite | Intense, harsh as smoke | Very strong | Skip the wood on a long cook. The lump charcoal sears hot and clean. |
Red Oak
Red oak is the traditional wood for Santa Maria style barbecue. The smoke is medium-bodied and clean and lifts the beef instead of competing with it. On the Central Coast it’s sold as red oak; the tree is coast live oak. Outside California, use post oak or white oak.
Cherry
Cherry gives a mild, fruity smoke and turns the crust a deep mahogany. On beef it works best blended: about 70 percent oak to 30 percent cherry keeps the oak backbone with a sweet edge.
Almond and Pecan
Almond is the California orchard wood: sweet, mild, with clean ash, like a softer oak. Pecan is a milder cousin of hickory, nutty and hard to over-smoke. Either one is a safe step past oak.
Hickory and Mesquite
Both are heavy. Hickory runs bacony and sharp and buries a lean cut, so use one chunk in an oak fire at most. Mesquite wood turns acrid over a long cook; save a small chunk for the last 5 minutes. Mesquite lump charcoal is different: it lights fast and sears hot with only a light touch of smoke.
What goes on the plate is in the sides and the sauce.
Use seasoned wood
Wood should be dried 6 to 12 months. Green wood makes thick white smoke that tastes bitter. You want thin, blue, almost invisible smoke, which means seasoned wood and good airflow.
Charcoal and Other Fuel
Lump Charcoal
Pure hardwood burned down to carbon, with no binders. It lights faster, burns hotter and answers the vents quicker than briquettes, but it burns less evenly. In a kettle it’s the closest thing to red oak coals, and the best fuel for a hard sear.
Briquettes
Briquettes burn longer and more evenly, which helps on a smoke at 225°F. Let them ash over completely before the meat goes on, and skip match-light briquettes: the lighter fluid taste stays in the meat.
Split Logs
Full splits burned down to a deep bed of coals are the traditional Santa Maria fire. You need a fire pit or a Santa Maria grill with a raised grate. If you have the setup, it’s the best-tasting way to cook tri tip.
Gas and Pellets
Gas trades smoke for control; a smoker box of chips adds some back. Pellets run the fire for you with a milder smoke, so use oak or an oak blend to make the smoke read on a lean cut. The steps for each: gas grill and pellet smoker.
Chips or Chunks
Match the form of the wood to the grill, not to the length of the cook.
Chunks for Charcoal
On a kettle or smoker, set 2 or 3 chunks on the coals. A chunk smolders slowly and gives steady smoke for the whole cook, short or long. On a kamado one chunk is enough, because the dome holds the smoke in.
Chips for Gas
Chips burn fast, so they suit a smoker box or a foil packet on a lit burner. A handful starts smoking in about 5 minutes. Skip the soak: wet chips steam before they smoke.
Pellets for Pellet Grills
Pellets are made for a pellet grill’s auger. On any other grill, a pellet tube in the cook chamber is the way to use them.
Controlling the Heat
Every grill is a different lever for the same job: hot to sear, cooler to bring the center up to your pull temperature.
On a Santa Maria Grill
No lid and no vents, so height is the dial. Crank the grate down to 4 to 6 inches over the coals to sear, then up to 8 to 10 inches to finish. If fat flares, raise the grate an inch. A hot spot in the coal bed gets a splash of water from a bottle, never fresh wood. Full steps: Santa Maria Style Grill.
On a Kettle or Kamado
Air is the dial. The bottom vent feeds the fire; the top vent pulls heat and smoke across the meat and stays mostly open. Build a two-zone fire: coals on one side, nothing on the other. For a smoke at 225°F, start with the bottom vent a quarter open and adjust from there.
Flare-Ups
Dripping fat causes them. Slide the roast to the cool side until the flames die down. In a covered grill, don’t spray water: it kicks up ash and drops the temperature.
Lighting the Fire
Use a chimney starter. Fill it, light paper or a starter cube underneath, and wait 15 to 20 minutes until the top coals ash over. No lighter fluid.
Which Method for Your Grill
Each grill has its own walkthrough in The Cook.
- Santa Maria Style Grill
The original. Red oak coals, heat set by the height of the grate.
- Charcoal Grill
A kettle with a two-zone fire. The method most home cooks use.
- Gas Grill
Two zones on the burners and a smoker box for smoke.
- Kamado
Ceramic that sears hard, then holds a low finish.
- Smoker
The deepest wood smoke, at 225°F, with a sear to finish.
- Pellet Smoker
The most hands-off. Oak pellets, then a sear.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best wood for tri tip?
Red oak is the best all-around wood for tri tip and the traditional Santa Maria choice. It gives a clean, medium smoke that lifts the beef without burying it. Post oak or white oak are the closest substitutes outside California, and cherry is the best milder choice, alone or blended with oak. Keep hickory and mesquite to a single chunk.
What wood do they use for Santa Maria tri tip?
Santa Maria tri tip is cooked over native coast live oak, sold as red oak. It burns clean and steady and gives the regional style its flavor. If you can’t get red oak, use post oak.
Can I use mesquite for tri tip?
Only as a finishing wood: a small chunk on hot coals for the last 5 minutes. As the main smoke on a long cook it turns acrid and bitter. Mesquite lump charcoal is a different story; it sears hot and clean.
Should I use lump charcoal or briquettes for tri tip?
Lump for a hot sear and a clean flavor, since it has no binders. Briquettes for a long, steady smoke, since they burn more evenly. Let briquettes ash over completely before cooking. Setup for each is in the charcoal grill method.
What temperature should I smoke tri tip at?
225°F is the standard. Figure 30 to 40 minutes per pound to reach 115 to 125°F before the sear (full smoker steps). At 275 to 300°F it’s faster with a firmer crust and less smoke; probe early, because the window between done and overdone is narrow.